Score: 9

"Good but not as good"

submission: the Last of the Dashkin

date: December 13, 2009

Excellent as always. The art is ridiculously beautiful. Everything is spot on.

I have a few gripes though. It seems like just an introduction, and not a story at all, but I guess that's the intent. It leaves you feeling cheated!

You also seemed to rely too much on narration. Even if it is supposed to be like a story book, it can feel redundant when the narration tells you he's secretly lonely and jealous of other animals who are together with each other, while the action on screen tells you exactly the same thing.

Score: 4

"badly executed"

submission: Pixel Grower

date: August 11, 2009

Good concept, bad execution.

1. Special pixels aren't special after level 3 or so
2. The gameplay never changes
3. All you do is move your mouse back and forth after level 3 or so. This isn't a game, it's a flash application where you move your mouse back and forth.

Score: 8

"Sound quality..."

submission: Hillside Settlement

date: July 20, 2009

The animation was really wonderful, but the sound quality is atrocious. I thought my speakers were going to explode. Please... when you do your next flash, don't compress the sound past 128kb/s.

It's the year 2009. 2.5MB vs 3.5MB is no longer an issue.

Score: 8

"cool"

submission: Crouching Kitten

date: March 27, 2009

But next time don't compress the sound quality to hell please. It isn't the year 2000 anymore.

Score: 0

"this.."

submission: Click Me - Curse You

date: February 16, 2009

this is not new, interesting, or entertaining. Please be more original.

Score: 1

"eh..."

submission: Audio Mix #003

date: February 7, 2009

not a bad song, but the flash portal is for flash... there's an audio portal for a reason. If you want to showcase a song, put it in a game or movie.

Score: 10

"shit"

submission: Fallen Angel Ep. 1 (Pt3)

date: November 2, 2008

I remember when the teaser came out 4 years ago!

That was by far the most amazing flash I've seen, and being a flash artist myself, I can't get over the amount of detail you put in.

I can't really say anything that hasn't been said, so all I want to know is, ETA for episode 2? :D I hope it doesn't take 4 years again...

Score: 7

"blah"

submission: The Tutorial Collab '08

date: August 31, 2008

Why are there AS2 tutorials in there?

Score: 8

"good"

submission: Bull's "Meteor Garden"

date: August 24, 2008

its good, only next time increase the file size... (sounds were too compressed)

Score: 8

"meh.."

submission: Valhalla Knights 2

date: July 22, 2008

I don't want to be an asshole, but I've seen 4 anime now where some lonely single guy randomly finds a naked chick with super powers that he has to protect.
It's just not extremely original.

That said, the animation was great, I just wish the sounds and music weren't so compressed. The voice acting was good as well.